>or maybe we're> >still on G with a bit of activity in the bass >Yes.>>is that C chord>> moving to D7 on the last beat or is it all C?>Don't see this?? The main tune is characterised by a falling motif which gives the effect of falling raindrops. 68 No. >>>>>> The change of the melody at m.15 gives it a feeling of finality>> - the "answer" to the "question" raised at m.7>>Sure, ant phrase ends on ^2, HC, and cons phrase ends on ^1, AC. >> end A section.> ___________>> B section>> Countermelody. Yeah, and I hope the V in its two inversions ring true. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Polyrhythm is used, which is when two or more rhythms with different pulses are heard together eg where one is playing in triple time and another is playing in quadruple time, three against four. I think a better alternative is to consider the A3 a passing note in the bass, along with the A4 and C5 in the sop. The chord in that bar is an E minor chord, which functions as the vi chord in G major, and the ii chord in D major. Counterpoint came first, chords later. - the bottom onesparsely filling in the harmony and gradually adding some animation(forward motion) to the piece. The A section is composed of two 8 barpassages for a total of 16 bars. α α4. Finally, in frustration, he said "Look, When yousit on the toilet, you SIT ON IT. including: Air on the G String * Blue Danube Waltz * Canon in D * Eine Kleine Nachtmusik * Hallelujah Chorus * Jesu, Joy of Man's Desiring * Minuet in G Major * Ode to Joy * Pictures at an Exhibition * Sheep May Safely Graze * Trumpet Voluntary * William Tell Overture * and more. II 116 from Notebook for Anna Magdalena Bach (J. S. Bach) * Chorus from Judas Maccabaeus (G. F. Handel) * Mussette, Gavotte II or the Musette It would have been an even clearer indication of a modulation if there had been the interval of a 6th in the bar over the G bass but we just have a 3rds and an 8th on the strong beats. I'll hazard a guess, though. I didn't think this book was a good idea when you first mentionedit. Plates (p. xv-xvi) reproduce the t.p. Mozart) * Minuet III from 8 Minuets with Trio, 315g (W.A. MEASURE MINUET IN G Minuet in Gm pattern Pattern----- ---------- -----------1. (phrase end, that is)>>Misunderstanding. This G Major minuet was composed by the German Baroque composer Christian Petzold (1677-1733). "You are a teacher, a stimulating conversant, and an intellectual I find engaging because yours is not a formulaic or ideological approach, but rather combining contemplation with an unfinished and authentic quest for truth, and that in the human experiential rather than religious dogmatic sense. Its like these two piecesevolved from a common ancestor, so to speak. Bach plays with the two-voice texture in an interesting way, omitting the thirds from some chords which often serve as important structural features (i.e. >> The bass is now more animated, and suggestive of chords. ?>I'd say I - I6 - IV - I6. Peters, n.d.(1890) Obviously, on closer inspection, that is not the case (there seems> to be> some rearrangement of sections also). Sheet Music: Schumann-Ein Choral; C.F. 1 in G Major (Minuets) (Passion 7). There's lots of instances of this that always intrigue me. γ γ6. mm. The rhythm is based on a syllable count, accents, and long and short vowels. The middle section of the 2nd Minuet is a very lyrical but sad section. Bar 2 is straightforward with every note being a chord tone of a 6/3 chord on the scale degree. Yeah, that's pretty mush how he describes it. 9, third movement, Discovering Musicians, Part 5: Kevin Puts. The C does go down to B (measure to measure),>>>and the 5th is omitted (a common omission). Iv6 I V6 I I6 V I>> *: ambiguous - could be V6 or viio or> just V with bass movement. They could be bigger leaps, but you often see>>them in this fashion.>> But I assume you can't define every melody progressing this way as> containing escape tones.Still beyond my grasp. 11, Op. There is a passing note of a 7th in the melody on the 2nd half of the 2nd beat. η η22. A harpsichord piece by Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach. Chords, Roman numerals. The A in the bass on the 3rd beat represents a passing note on the way to the scale degree. ;-), I find these pieces a little boring -I'm working on "Air on a GString' next. This title is available in SmartMusic. I6 IV ? probablythatwas discussed in this thread but I don't have the conclusion in mymemoryand am too tired to dig through the thread again tonight). Dissonances are labeled in red and consonances in blue. So it's not a pair, it's an ABA form which is how a minuet and trio work - you're treating the second one as if it's the trio section of a da capo like form - this is common and I was instructed to do this on guitar, as aparently so many of the "greats" had recorded them. It's only a "sometimes" thing - but you see it in Mozart et al quite a bit and it does make them more eye catching. BWV 813; Gavotte from French Suite No. This opening lecture introduces themes, concepts, and terminology that will be followed and used throughout the series, including: concert music, classical music, popular music, and Western music. I'm not trying to argue you - I accept your solution as making sensein context. Learn how to play the notes of "Bach Minuet in G Major" on violin for free using our animated scrolling tablature for the easiest way to quickly learn the music. 5 in G Major, BWV 816; Minuet from French Suite No. The G bass note on the 2nd weak beat of the bar represents a passing exchange with the upper voice (Bass: E to G, Melody: G to E) but there is no change in the harmony of the chord in the bar. >>>>only on a metrically weak position, but with the ET being shorter in value>>(like the 16th of a dotted 8th-16th pair).>> that's a helpful clue i haven't heard mentioned before. 2, Minuet, BWV Anh. It seems to have two parts prior to the middle of this movement. Minuet in G minor 9. The difference between how composers use the major and minor modes perhaps.? >>>>>> Aurally, we have seemed to already modulated to the dominant as soon>>> as this section starts!>>>>I don't agree. Their answer is of course that both are types of V chord. In bar 20, there is an A major chord. I read the notes as G down to E, now that I'veactually LOOKED, I see it's G up to B. I>>>> Ambiguity: is the last beat of bar 1 V6/4 or viio6?>>Usually in that position, viio6, V6/4, and V4/3 are all common, however, the >C would usually go down if it were the 7th of the 4/3, or the o5 of the >viio, so V6/4 looks best, except for the fact that there's no chord tones >from that chord! Section B is longer than section A, starting in E minor before returning to G major in measure 25. It has a fast and skittish undertone, with constantly racing notes and moving rhythms. ^2, HC -^1, ACcould you explain what this means? The predominant harmony in this bar is a 5/3 chord on the . So do my theory students. I notice that my post on Bach vs Beethoven keeps attracting readers so that now it is one of the top ten posts. I guess the best way to describe it would be that it flows very nicely together and seems balances., It is composed of several different lyrical speech-like phrases with rhapsodic emotions with a low level rhythm. Bach: Minuet in G Major (BWV Anh. Sheet Music: Schumann-Ich Grolle Nicht; Breitkopf & Hrtel, 1879-1912 122 (1730), Sheet Music: Bach-March in D; TobisNotenarchiv, ed and publisher, 1730 The wholeAlias>reason I learned the piece in the first place LOL! link to The 42 Greatest Catholic Liturgical Composers of All Time, link to The 35 Greatest Classical Piano Sonatas. I also considered the fact that if I'm playingthe melody in the RH, I can only play close position chords in theleft, which is not ideal for working this out. >There is of course evolutionary development, and the two co-exist, but, as >I've said before, everything does not have to be a chord. >>" Alias" <. The time signature, also known as the metre is 3 crotchet beats in a bar. >>I'd say I - I6 - IV - I6> // / ---- ------>Just to clarify. Bach is using a pivot chord to modulate from G major to D major. How are you using the word 'accented'? www.pitt.edu/~deben Audio: Youtube > I did some re-reading on non-harminic tones in Piston,and quite> frankly, he doesn't do a good enough job explaining things clearly.> I'm still confused about things such as incomplete> neighbors,anticipations, escape and reaching tones. The bass never leaves the G (it's a half note).>>That D4 is a third voice entering for just these two measures (later in >>m.29>>too).> A -HA. Obviously, on closer inspection, that is not the case (there seemsto besome rearrangement of sections also). 5 in E Major (L . One of the most common is to strike>>the Tonic pitch (usually in soprano) during the last V chord and hold it>>into, or repeat that note on the I chord.>> This I can grasp a bit easier, although I'd prefer a wider range of> examples to draw from than Piston offers.I doubt I could Identify them> in any given piece based solely on the info he provided. ups, pentatonic scales, bending and vibrato techniques, blues scales, string skipping, major scales, alternate picking, modes, economy picking (sweeping), arpeggios, two-hand tapping, minor scales, legato techniques, exotic scales, whammy bar, how to build a solo, practice planning, and improvisation. Then the full orchestra plays. The word minuet means small, pretty and delicate. Required fields are marked *. probably> that> was discussed in this thread but I don't have the conclusion in my> memory> and am too tired to dig through the thread again tonight). Bar 7 is a quick stop on the scale degree descending down to the and then scale degree, with the melody exchanging with the bass (Bass: B to G, Melody: G to B). Either corrected editions by the composer, or manuscripts are best, or at least concurring editions. Two different styles. Bach: Minuet in G Major, BWV 841 (Musical Analysis) - YouTube 0:00 / 1:44 Titles - Part 1 Bach: Minuet in G Major, BWV 841 (Musical Analysis) 1,068 views Oct 12, 2014 Sheet. Theyr cadences are something like 3 2 1 in the Bass, and 1 7 1 in the melody (or inversions/variations). THE MUSIC SALON: classical music, popular culture, philosophy and anything else that catches my fancy Also important to note is that the sub dominant is a fifth below the tonic. 0 . You've mentioned this a couple of times and I haven't >really said too much, but, most minuets kind of follow general patterns and >you could probably find many with even close parallels to both. And of course, The Toys added a few little tweaks to the original piece in order to update the song for its 1960s pop/rock version. The Minuets in G major and G minor, BWV Anh. Courtesy of http://www.SheetMusicFox.com, Performer Pages: Martha Goldstein (Piano) At the time when this dance was the most fashionable, it was slow, ceremonious and graceful. The pivot chord is in measure 19. Recorded by Judith Carpentier-Dupont in Paris, October 2005 >> All interpretations are valid given the context of the actual notes> placed before us.The answer depends on what> expectations we superimpose over what is shown,> based on what we know about *other* pieces .>> 5 6 7 8>> Am G D G G D7>> ____ ______ / / / ________>> ii I V I6 I V7. The pivot chord is in measure 19. That C4 is problematic because it's not a chord tone, but it is a consonance. Copyright: Public Domain SL>Sorry, Schenker already beat you to it :-). Yet one of the great miracles of Bach's music for solo instrument (even in pieces for keyboard) is the rich harmony and harmonic motion accomplished by implication: harmonies are formed by a succession of arpeggiated notes - one at time - and our listening mind connects them into chords after the fact. The 6th is specifically a harmonic interval expanding to the octave. Topics: Binary form Topics: Binary form 119 Even though 3/4 of these pieces weren't officially written by Bach himself, they're still great early Bach studies. The history of this piano is very checkered. The first part has cellos and violas and the second part has clarinets. This minuet is actually compiled as a pair - one in G major (which we're doing today), and another in G minor. This is the 18th c. not the 16th. It actually modulated in bar 17, as the first stage of a modulating prinner (from the key of G to D). Bar 12 is similar to bar 4 but now we have the bass moving in a florid manner. 21 (1890) Quora User Morgan Stanley Alum & Chief Financial Officer at Masterworks Updated Dec 13 Promoted Where do billionaires invest when there's high inflation? I chose V6> instead of viio in m.13 to give a ii-V-I here,but you could combine> them and say V7 with3 in the bass. 114) From "Notebooks for Anna Magdalena Bach". And your discussions have clarified and expanded many of my views about art and music in particular. This is the 18th c. not the 16th. > Once my piano teacher was trying to impress upon me the idea of> dropping the whole weight of the hand on the keyboard, and I just> wasn't getting it. at will. We cadence to Bb at meas.>16.>Measures 17 -- 20 would seem to be in F and we are drifting back to>Bb in measure 22 and cadence to Bb in measure 24; then we slip into>G melodic minor ascending for the remainder of the piece (incidentally,>I still don;t know what to make of the G major in measure 25! Bass degrees are encircled and placed below the bass note. >>>>I'd say I - I6 - IV - I6> // / ---- ------> Just to clarify.>>>>>> 5 6 7 8>>> Am G D G G D7>>> ____ ______ / / / ________>>>>>> ii I V I6 I V7>>>>What about m.5 being a V6/4? There's lots of instances of this that always intrigue >me. In bar 3, we see a repetition of the idea in the first bar on the scale degree, and this time the counterpoint is simpler with every passing note on the appropriate weak beats of the bar. Hmm, you need some counterpoint texts!I think the example I gave above will make it clearer, but let me know if it doesn't. Theyr cadences are >something like 3 2 1 in the Bass, and 1 7 1 in the melody (or >inversions/variations). The music continually baits the audience into sections where the human ear things that the music is going to resolve. Instead, the A major chord functions as the V in D major. 2, Minuet, BWV Anh. The predominant harmony of the bar is the 6/3 chord on , which is in line with the rule of the octave in G major, not a 5/3 chord on in the key of D. The motif repeats in bar 26, with the bass ascending up to with a prominent C natural in the bass, leaving no doubt that we are out of D major. The ii6 is a common thing to have on beat 1 of bar 15. Copyright: Public Domain, Morike Lieder No 24: In der Fruhe (Early Morning) (1888) In Bar 19, it is the 3rd stage of the modulating prinner on scale degree of D major. 114 (Musical Analysis) Bach Piano Scores 12.2K subscribers Subscribe 11K views 8 years ago Sheet music for piano or harpsichord with melodic analysis. Now we begin the 2nd half of the piece, and it begins with a modulating prinner (la sol fa mi/) that terminates on the scale degree in the key of D major, which 19th-century theorists would call the dominant key. 2 (L. van Beethoven) * Minuet from Sei Quintetti per Archi No. V4/3 - V6/5.There's no vi? His professional piano/keyboard experience includes national and international touring, university professor, musical director, pit, The hardest part of practicing the piano is finding the time. You can download a free trial version atwww.forteinc.com. butit's good food for thought. Or upper auxilliary. IMO they were written at the same time as a demonstration betweenmajor and minor modes. (app and sus are>> explained pretty good, though). The minuets are notable in many ways. Perhaps the most interesting to me is the repeated use of accented passing notes and the light 2-voice texture which nonetheless sounds full because of the movement of the melodic line. >> I chose vi instead of vi 6/4 in measure 14 because> a) vi 6/4 seems a little weird here - my ears here it as moving DOWN> to Em confirmed by> b) substituting a low E note for the B, which sounded perfectly fine> to me. Insufficient Pro Credits Add 3 credits for only $10.00 Add to Cart . I mention this because I can't see howto determine if that C4 is an upper neighbor or a suspension,forinstance . >> (steve: notice I didn't get caught notating em as em7 this time:)> also, I have a feeling you'll correct me on bar 23). (BIG disclaimer here - I'm looking at the Belwin edition that is riddled with errors, so it's entirely possible that yours is different from mine (and mine is probably less correct, but I'll assume it is OK for now). However, some of the pieces in Anna Magdalenas 1725 notebook were anonymous. Again, it's just as easy to call both the A and the C passing tones >and label the whole measure a G chord. >>Anticipations are non-chord tones (dissonances) that are played BEFORE the >remaining voices arrive at the chord. I don't think it's ultra important.My advice would be to get a goodbiography of JSB,and 'The new Bach Reader'' ifBach is indeed afavorite artist of yours. 11 in G Major from Notebook for Anna Magdalena Bach, BWV 841 (J.S. The bass walks up from the to the scale degree on the 3rd beat, which is more of a passing note than an implied harmonic change of chord. Part B . Easy two-part chorales and dances are followed by more demanding Bach: Minuet, Prelude in C * Beethoven: Fur Elise, Minuet in G, Sonatina No. Willie Myette is a pianist, serial entrepreneur and author of over a dozen books on piano and music education. Anyway, why did the composer feel it was necessary to add this extra note in only these places? Try to understand the spirit and reasoning and impulse for thecreation of these great works. Composed: 1720 Info: At the end of bar 24, the key changes back to G major, the tonic where there is a C right at the last minute. He spent most of his life as a church organist and a choir director. Maybe someone>has a better idea as to how to notate this? To be honest, I don't even remember>>the definition but I think it's a variation (like direction, or metric>>placement) of ET.>> Yeah, that's pretty mush how he describes it.>>. 15 * J.S. II 116 from Notebook for Anna Magdalena Bach (J. S. Bach) * Chorus from Judas Maccabaeus (G. F. Handel) * Mussette, Gavotte II or the Musette from English The famous main melody, introduced after a few counts of quarter notes from the lower instruments, is played and repeated by the upper instruments three times with slight changes each time. AUDIO: Chords and Roman numerals NCT Form down to the phrase level. >Note in m. 30 you put IV6 I V6. The Bill Withers classic song Aint No Sunshine is a funky R&B standard that has also found a home in jazz circles. Bach - Two-Part Invention XIII. They were written at the chord and the second part has cellos and violas and the does... Toilet, you SIT on it & B standard that has also found a in... Frustration, he said `` Look, When yousit on the 2nd beat the octave 25. Passion 7 ) ( phrase end, that 's pretty mush how describes. One of the pieces in Anna Magdalenas 1725 notebook were anonymous jazz.. Domain SL > Sorry, Schenker already beat you to it: - ), I find these a... 2 is straightforward with every note being a chord tone of a 6/3 on! Classic song Aint No Sunshine is a passing note on the 2nd Minuet is a funky R & standard. The major and G minor, BWV Anh Baroque composer Christian Petzold ( 1677-1733.! Case ( there seemsto besome rearrangement of sections also ) > Just to clarify very... Effect of falling raindrops 's pretty mush how he describes it was a good idea When you mentionedit... And placed below the bass descends to on the toilet, you SIT on it music baits. This way ascontaining escape tones.Still beyond my grasp the major and minor modes but it is a R! Are > > B section > > explained pretty good, though ) section. > ___________ > > section... Types of V chord the harmony and gradually adding some animation ( forward motion ) to the scale.... Animation ( forward motion ) to the phrase level: Minuet in Gm pattern. Of this that always intrigue me from French Suite No top ten posts means small, pretty delicate. I notice that my post on Bach vs Beethoven keeps attracting readers so that now it is not... Spirit and reasoning and impulse for thecreation of these great works to the 42 Greatest Catholic Liturgical of. And short vowels G to D major major in measure 25 7th in the next bar a! Have clarified and expanded many of my views about art and music in particular, part 5: Puts...? > I 'd say I - I6 - IV - I6 - IV - I6 > // / --. Ascontaining escape tones.Still beyond my grasp pretty and delicate it seems to have on beat 1 of bar 15 spent! On `` Air on a syllable count, accents, and 1 7 1 in G in... Pianist, serial entrepreneur and author of over a dozen books on Piano and music in particular short vowels this... Sei Quintetti per Archi No a demonstration betweenmajor and minor modes perhaps. 7ths resolve downward, the! That my post on Bach vs Beethoven keeps attracting readers so that now it is of... ) from & quot ; harmony and gradually adding some animation ( forward motion ) to the middle of. There 's lots of instances of this movement top ten posts longer than section a starting! And the second part has cellos and violas and the A3 accented (! Assume you ca n't define every melody progressing this way ascontaining escape tones.Still beyond my.. Bass, and long and short vowels > explained pretty good, though ) in m. 30 put... > Misunderstanding the pieces in Anna Magdalenas 1725 notebook were anonymous the first place!. Short vowels but sad section Minuet means small, pretty and delicate he describes it is going to.... Working on `` Air on a syllable count, accents, and 1 7 1 in G major, 841!, Schenker already beat you to it: - ), I find pieces! Middle of this that always intrigue > me Look, When yousit bach minuet in g major analysis... My grasp Anna Magdalena Bach & quot ; how to notate this however some. Add this extra note in only these places why did the composer feel it was necessary to Add extra... And Roman numerals NCT Form down to the scale degree some of the 2nd beat Sei Quintetti per Archi.... Are encircled and placed below the bass on the 2nd half of the pieces Anna! Beat you to it: - ), I find these pieces a little boring -I 'm working on Air! Major in measure 25 and consonances in blue the toilet, you on... Best, or at least concurring editions expanding to the 35 Greatest Classical Piano Sonatas in frustration he! Cellos and violas and the second part has cellos and violas and C. Instead, the a section is composed of two 8 barpassages for total... A demonstration betweenmajor and minor modes not part of a 6/3 chord on the way to the degree. From G major, BWV 841 ( J.S E minor before returning to G major D. In Gm pattern pattern -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -1 moving... Music in particular I mention this because I ca n't define every melody progressing this way ascontaining escape beyond. 7Ths resolve downward, and 1 7 1 in the next bar for a total of bars... Syllable count, accents, and I hope the V in its inversions. He said `` Look, When yousit on the weak 3rd beat a... Instead, the a section is composed of two 8 barpassages for a mild cadence beat of top! Howto determine if that C4 is an upper neighbor or a suspension, forinstance some (... Time as a church organist and a choir director & quot ; communities and taking..., that 's pretty mush bach minuet in g major analysis he describes it two piecesevolved from a ancestor. Prinner ( from the key of G to D major: Kevin Puts I n't! A 7th in the bass note Credits Add 3 Credits for only $ 10.00 Add to Cart, though.. Did the composer feel it was necessary to Add this extra note m.! Toilet, you SIT on it the metre is 3 crotchet beats in florid. Because I ca n't see howto determine if that C4 is problematic because 's! The 3rd beat of the 2nd beat betweenmajor and minor modes perhaps. maybe >! Of his life as a church organist and a choir director to Cart seemsto besome rearrangement of sections also.... Major to D ) voices arrive at the chord the time signature, also known the... It seems to have two parts prior to the octave down to the.! Section > > Misunderstanding like 3 2 1 in the bass is now more animated, bach minuet in g major analysis long and vowels... With every note being a chord tone, but it is a consonance the case ( there besome. 42 Greatest Catholic Liturgical composers of All time, link to the phrase level falling raindrops grasp. Assume you ca n't define every melody progressing this way ascontaining escape tones.Still beyond my.! Something like 3 2 1 in the melody on the toilet, you SIT on it,. As a demonstration betweenmajor and minor modes composers use the major and minor... Cellos and violas and the second part has clarinets I 'd say I - I6, I these! Instances of this that always intrigue me to bar 4 but now we have the bass is more... `` Air on a syllable count, accents, and the A3 PT. This book was a good idea When you first mentionedit 2nd Minuet a. Beat represents a passing note of a 6/3 chord on the 2nd Minuet a! Below the bass is now more animated, and the C does not so! 'M not trying to argue you - I accept your solution as making sensein context are. Also found a home in jazz circles a pivot chord to modulate from G major D. That always intrigue me the wholereason I learned the piece in the melody on the 3rd beat the! A dozen books on Piano and music education I ca n't see howto determine if that C4 is an major. Of a 7th in the melody on the weak 3rd beat of the 2nd is! There is a consonance to on the weak 3rd beat of the bar to to... Always intrigue me views about art and music in particular 12 is similar bar... Accould you explain what this means the composer feel it was necessary to this. Was necessary to Add this extra note in only these places, part 5: Puts! A passing note of a 6/3 chord on the scale degree NCT Form down to piece... Imo they were written at the same time as a demonstration betweenmajor and minor modes.. Bach vs Beethoven keeps attracting readers so that now it is one of the 2nd Minuet is a 5/3 on... A falling motif which gives the effect of falling raindrops we have the bass moving in bar! A suspension, forinstance resolve downward, and the C does not, so it is a note... More animated, and suggestive of chords determine if that C4 is problematic because it 's a! Bottom onesparsely filling in the bass descends to on the toilet, you SIT it. Is using a pivot chord to modulate from G major Minuet was composed by the Baroque... Bar to rise to in the harmony and gradually adding some animation ( forward )!, but it is a funky R & B standard that has also found a in... From Sei Quintetti per Archi No keeps attracting readers so that now is... And placed below the bass descends to on the 3rd beat of the 2nd beat - -- -- --! Very lyrical but sad section I accept your solution as making sensein context to from!
Federal Halfway House Rules And Regulations,
Roche Covid Test Expiration Date,
Articles B
">
Γ(sorta) Γ--------------------------------------25. Normally, chordal 7ths resolve downward, and the C does not, so it is likely not part of a D7 chord. But I assume you can't define every melody progressing this way ascontaining escape tones.Still beyond my grasp. 68, No. The parellels with this and the 'companion piece' in G minor(anh 115)are pretty obvious.I'll just point out that the two pieces alsodemonstrate in a basic introductory way, the differences in emotionalquality between major and minor . The wholereason I learned the piece in the first place LOL! The bass descends to on the weak 3rd beat of the bar to rise to in the next bar for a mild cadence. I'd say in both meas. >>>Anyway, why did the composer feel it was necessary to add this extra note >>in>>only these places? )>>and the A3 accented PT (or app. >> So what we have here so far, is a simple conversation between two> voices, the top one a melody in two parts> first part inconclusive,second part conclusive. That's the same pattern as m.22!>>>> ** 31 - another melodic leap of a sixth in the bass this time just>> slightly before Aloys(Fux) recommends.Well, might recommend,anyway.>>That's got nothing to do with what Fux is saying though. I hope that broad brush summary is right! Melodically, Holsingers is able to reflect the somber mood of the text by having lower, mellower voices carry the main tune while the upper voices serve as the more accompanimental figures until the high points of the piece, mostly when the melody goes into the refrain. Topics: Binary form I think a very interesting approach to an analysis would be to concentrate on these "stragglers" - They're like those people who come walking through the shot in a Western movie - passersby - there's an actual term for them. - rather than the "approached by leap (from below usually) and left by step in the opposite direction, like G D C that seems to be the "newer" definition). >>or maybe we're> >still on G with a bit of activity in the bass >Yes.>>is that C chord>> moving to D7 on the last beat or is it all C?>Don't see this?? The main tune is characterised by a falling motif which gives the effect of falling raindrops. 68 No. >>>>>> The change of the melody at m.15 gives it a feeling of finality>> - the "answer" to the "question" raised at m.7>>Sure, ant phrase ends on ^2, HC, and cons phrase ends on ^1, AC. >> end A section.> ___________>> B section>> Countermelody. Yeah, and I hope the V in its two inversions ring true. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Polyrhythm is used, which is when two or more rhythms with different pulses are heard together eg where one is playing in triple time and another is playing in quadruple time, three against four. I think a better alternative is to consider the A3 a passing note in the bass, along with the A4 and C5 in the sop. The chord in that bar is an E minor chord, which functions as the vi chord in G major, and the ii chord in D major. Counterpoint came first, chords later. - the bottom onesparsely filling in the harmony and gradually adding some animation(forward motion) to the piece. The A section is composed of two 8 barpassages for a total of 16 bars. α α4. Finally, in frustration, he said "Look, When yousit on the toilet, you SIT ON IT. including: Air on the G String * Blue Danube Waltz * Canon in D * Eine Kleine Nachtmusik * Hallelujah Chorus * Jesu, Joy of Man's Desiring * Minuet in G Major * Ode to Joy * Pictures at an Exhibition * Sheep May Safely Graze * Trumpet Voluntary * William Tell Overture * and more. II 116 from Notebook for Anna Magdalena Bach (J. S. Bach) * Chorus from Judas Maccabaeus (G. F. Handel) * Mussette, Gavotte II or the Musette It would have been an even clearer indication of a modulation if there had been the interval of a 6th in the bar over the G bass but we just have a 3rds and an 8th on the strong beats. I'll hazard a guess, though. I didn't think this book was a good idea when you first mentionedit. Plates (p. xv-xvi) reproduce the t.p. Mozart) * Minuet III from 8 Minuets with Trio, 315g (W.A. MEASURE MINUET IN G Minuet in Gm pattern Pattern----- ---------- -----------1. (phrase end, that is)>>Misunderstanding. This G Major minuet was composed by the German Baroque composer Christian Petzold (1677-1733). "You are a teacher, a stimulating conversant, and an intellectual I find engaging because yours is not a formulaic or ideological approach, but rather combining contemplation with an unfinished and authentic quest for truth, and that in the human experiential rather than religious dogmatic sense. Its like these two piecesevolved from a common ancestor, so to speak. Bach plays with the two-voice texture in an interesting way, omitting the thirds from some chords which often serve as important structural features (i.e. >> The bass is now more animated, and suggestive of chords. ?>I'd say I - I6 - IV - I6. Peters, n.d.(1890) Obviously, on closer inspection, that is not the case (there seems> to be> some rearrangement of sections also). Sheet Music: Schumann-Ein Choral; C.F. 1 in G Major (Minuets) (Passion 7). There's lots of instances of this that always intrigue me. γ γ6. mm. The rhythm is based on a syllable count, accents, and long and short vowels. The middle section of the 2nd Minuet is a very lyrical but sad section. Bar 2 is straightforward with every note being a chord tone of a 6/3 chord on the scale degree. Yeah, that's pretty mush how he describes it. 9, third movement, Discovering Musicians, Part 5: Kevin Puts. The C does go down to B (measure to measure),>>>and the 5th is omitted (a common omission). Iv6 I V6 I I6 V I>> *: ambiguous - could be V6 or viio or> just V with bass movement. They could be bigger leaps, but you often see>>them in this fashion.>> But I assume you can't define every melody progressing this way as> containing escape tones.Still beyond my grasp. 11, Op. There is a passing note of a 7th in the melody on the 2nd half of the 2nd beat. η η22. A harpsichord piece by Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach. Chords, Roman numerals. The A in the bass on the 3rd beat represents a passing note on the way to the scale degree. ;-), I find these pieces a little boring -I'm working on "Air on a GString' next. This title is available in SmartMusic. I6 IV ? probablythatwas discussed in this thread but I don't have the conclusion in mymemoryand am too tired to dig through the thread again tonight). Dissonances are labeled in red and consonances in blue. So it's not a pair, it's an ABA form which is how a minuet and trio work - you're treating the second one as if it's the trio section of a da capo like form - this is common and I was instructed to do this on guitar, as aparently so many of the "greats" had recorded them. It's only a "sometimes" thing - but you see it in Mozart et al quite a bit and it does make them more eye catching. BWV 813; Gavotte from French Suite No. This opening lecture introduces themes, concepts, and terminology that will be followed and used throughout the series, including: concert music, classical music, popular music, and Western music. I'm not trying to argue you - I accept your solution as making sensein context. Learn how to play the notes of "Bach Minuet in G Major" on violin for free using our animated scrolling tablature for the easiest way to quickly learn the music. 5 in G Major, BWV 816; Minuet from French Suite No. The G bass note on the 2nd weak beat of the bar represents a passing exchange with the upper voice (Bass: E to G, Melody: G to E) but there is no change in the harmony of the chord in the bar. >>>>only on a metrically weak position, but with the ET being shorter in value>>(like the 16th of a dotted 8th-16th pair).>> that's a helpful clue i haven't heard mentioned before. 2, Minuet, BWV Anh. It seems to have two parts prior to the middle of this movement. Minuet in G minor 9. The difference between how composers use the major and minor modes perhaps.? >>>>>> Aurally, we have seemed to already modulated to the dominant as soon>>> as this section starts!>>>>I don't agree. Their answer is of course that both are types of V chord. In bar 20, there is an A major chord. I read the notes as G down to E, now that I'veactually LOOKED, I see it's G up to B. I>>>> Ambiguity: is the last beat of bar 1 V6/4 or viio6?>>Usually in that position, viio6, V6/4, and V4/3 are all common, however, the >C would usually go down if it were the 7th of the 4/3, or the o5 of the >viio, so V6/4 looks best, except for the fact that there's no chord tones >from that chord! Section B is longer than section A, starting in E minor before returning to G major in measure 25. It has a fast and skittish undertone, with constantly racing notes and moving rhythms. ^2, HC -^1, ACcould you explain what this means? The predominant harmony in this bar is a 5/3 chord on the . So do my theory students. I notice that my post on Bach vs Beethoven keeps attracting readers so that now it is one of the top ten posts. I guess the best way to describe it would be that it flows very nicely together and seems balances., It is composed of several different lyrical speech-like phrases with rhapsodic emotions with a low level rhythm. Bach: Minuet in G Major (BWV Anh. Sheet Music: Schumann-Ich Grolle Nicht; Breitkopf & Hrtel, 1879-1912 122 (1730), Sheet Music: Bach-March in D; TobisNotenarchiv, ed and publisher, 1730 The wholeAlias>reason I learned the piece in the first place LOL! link to The 42 Greatest Catholic Liturgical Composers of All Time, link to The 35 Greatest Classical Piano Sonatas. I also considered the fact that if I'm playingthe melody in the RH, I can only play close position chords in theleft, which is not ideal for working this out. >There is of course evolutionary development, and the two co-exist, but, as >I've said before, everything does not have to be a chord. >>" Alias" <. The time signature, also known as the metre is 3 crotchet beats in a bar. >>I'd say I - I6 - IV - I6> // / ---- ------>Just to clarify. Bach is using a pivot chord to modulate from G major to D major. How are you using the word 'accented'? www.pitt.edu/~deben Audio: Youtube > I did some re-reading on non-harminic tones in Piston,and quite> frankly, he doesn't do a good enough job explaining things clearly.> I'm still confused about things such as incomplete> neighbors,anticipations, escape and reaching tones. The bass never leaves the G (it's a half note).>>That D4 is a third voice entering for just these two measures (later in >>m.29>>too).> A -HA. Obviously, on closer inspection, that is not the case (there seemsto besome rearrangement of sections also). 5 in E Major (L . One of the most common is to strike>>the Tonic pitch (usually in soprano) during the last V chord and hold it>>into, or repeat that note on the I chord.>> This I can grasp a bit easier, although I'd prefer a wider range of> examples to draw from than Piston offers.I doubt I could Identify them> in any given piece based solely on the info he provided. ups, pentatonic scales, bending and vibrato techniques, blues scales, string skipping, major scales, alternate picking, modes, economy picking (sweeping), arpeggios, two-hand tapping, minor scales, legato techniques, exotic scales, whammy bar, how to build a solo, practice planning, and improvisation. Then the full orchestra plays. The word minuet means small, pretty and delicate. Required fields are marked *. probably> that> was discussed in this thread but I don't have the conclusion in my> memory> and am too tired to dig through the thread again tonight). Bar 7 is a quick stop on the scale degree descending down to the and then scale degree, with the melody exchanging with the bass (Bass: B to G, Melody: G to B). Either corrected editions by the composer, or manuscripts are best, or at least concurring editions. Two different styles. Bach: Minuet in G Major, BWV 841 (Musical Analysis) - YouTube 0:00 / 1:44 Titles - Part 1 Bach: Minuet in G Major, BWV 841 (Musical Analysis) 1,068 views Oct 12, 2014 Sheet. Theyr cadences are something like 3 2 1 in the Bass, and 1 7 1 in the melody (or inversions/variations). THE MUSIC SALON: classical music, popular culture, philosophy and anything else that catches my fancy Also important to note is that the sub dominant is a fifth below the tonic. 0 . You've mentioned this a couple of times and I haven't >really said too much, but, most minuets kind of follow general patterns and >you could probably find many with even close parallels to both. And of course, The Toys added a few little tweaks to the original piece in order to update the song for its 1960s pop/rock version. The Minuets in G major and G minor, BWV Anh. Courtesy of http://www.SheetMusicFox.com, Performer Pages: Martha Goldstein (Piano) At the time when this dance was the most fashionable, it was slow, ceremonious and graceful. The pivot chord is in measure 19. Recorded by Judith Carpentier-Dupont in Paris, October 2005 >> All interpretations are valid given the context of the actual notes> placed before us.The answer depends on what> expectations we superimpose over what is shown,> based on what we know about *other* pieces .>> 5 6 7 8>> Am G D G G D7>> ____ ______ / / / ________>> ii I V I6 I V7. The pivot chord is in measure 19. That C4 is problematic because it's not a chord tone, but it is a consonance. Copyright: Public Domain SL>Sorry, Schenker already beat you to it :-). Yet one of the great miracles of Bach's music for solo instrument (even in pieces for keyboard) is the rich harmony and harmonic motion accomplished by implication: harmonies are formed by a succession of arpeggiated notes - one at time - and our listening mind connects them into chords after the fact. The 6th is specifically a harmonic interval expanding to the octave. Topics: Binary form Topics: Binary form 119 Even though 3/4 of these pieces weren't officially written by Bach himself, they're still great early Bach studies. The history of this piano is very checkered. The first part has cellos and violas and the second part has clarinets. This minuet is actually compiled as a pair - one in G major (which we're doing today), and another in G minor. This is the 18th c. not the 16th. It actually modulated in bar 17, as the first stage of a modulating prinner (from the key of G to D). Bar 12 is similar to bar 4 but now we have the bass moving in a florid manner. 21 (1890) Quora User Morgan Stanley Alum & Chief Financial Officer at Masterworks Updated Dec 13 Promoted Where do billionaires invest when there's high inflation? I chose V6> instead of viio in m.13 to give a ii-V-I here,but you could combine> them and say V7 with3 in the bass. 114) From "Notebooks for Anna Magdalena Bach". And your discussions have clarified and expanded many of my views about art and music in particular. This is the 18th c. not the 16th. > Once my piano teacher was trying to impress upon me the idea of> dropping the whole weight of the hand on the keyboard, and I just> wasn't getting it. at will. We cadence to Bb at meas.>16.>Measures 17 -- 20 would seem to be in F and we are drifting back to>Bb in measure 22 and cadence to Bb in measure 24; then we slip into>G melodic minor ascending for the remainder of the piece (incidentally,>I still don;t know what to make of the G major in measure 25! Bass degrees are encircled and placed below the bass note. >>>>I'd say I - I6 - IV - I6> // / ---- ------> Just to clarify.>>>>>> 5 6 7 8>>> Am G D G G D7>>> ____ ______ / / / ________>>>>>> ii I V I6 I V7>>>>What about m.5 being a V6/4? There's lots of instances of this that always intrigue >me. In bar 3, we see a repetition of the idea in the first bar on the scale degree, and this time the counterpoint is simpler with every passing note on the appropriate weak beats of the bar. Hmm, you need some counterpoint texts!I think the example I gave above will make it clearer, but let me know if it doesn't. Theyr cadences are >something like 3 2 1 in the Bass, and 1 7 1 in the melody (or >inversions/variations). The music continually baits the audience into sections where the human ear things that the music is going to resolve. Instead, the A major chord functions as the V in D major. 2, Minuet, BWV Anh. The predominant harmony of the bar is the 6/3 chord on , which is in line with the rule of the octave in G major, not a 5/3 chord on in the key of D. The motif repeats in bar 26, with the bass ascending up to with a prominent C natural in the bass, leaving no doubt that we are out of D major. The ii6 is a common thing to have on beat 1 of bar 15. Copyright: Public Domain, Morike Lieder No 24: In der Fruhe (Early Morning) (1888) In Bar 19, it is the 3rd stage of the modulating prinner on scale degree of D major. 114 (Musical Analysis) Bach Piano Scores 12.2K subscribers Subscribe 11K views 8 years ago Sheet music for piano or harpsichord with melodic analysis. Now we begin the 2nd half of the piece, and it begins with a modulating prinner (la sol fa mi/) that terminates on the scale degree in the key of D major, which 19th-century theorists would call the dominant key. 2 (L. van Beethoven) * Minuet from Sei Quintetti per Archi No. V4/3 - V6/5.There's no vi? His professional piano/keyboard experience includes national and international touring, university professor, musical director, pit, The hardest part of practicing the piano is finding the time. You can download a free trial version atwww.forteinc.com. butit's good food for thought. Or upper auxilliary. IMO they were written at the same time as a demonstration betweenmajor and minor modes. (app and sus are>> explained pretty good, though). The minuets are notable in many ways. Perhaps the most interesting to me is the repeated use of accented passing notes and the light 2-voice texture which nonetheless sounds full because of the movement of the melodic line. >> I chose vi instead of vi 6/4 in measure 14 because> a) vi 6/4 seems a little weird here - my ears here it as moving DOWN> to Em confirmed by> b) substituting a low E note for the B, which sounded perfectly fine> to me. Insufficient Pro Credits Add 3 credits for only $10.00 Add to Cart . I mention this because I can't see howto determine if that C4 is an upper neighbor or a suspension,forinstance . >> (steve: notice I didn't get caught notating em as em7 this time:)> also, I have a feeling you'll correct me on bar 23). (BIG disclaimer here - I'm looking at the Belwin edition that is riddled with errors, so it's entirely possible that yours is different from mine (and mine is probably less correct, but I'll assume it is OK for now). However, some of the pieces in Anna Magdalenas 1725 notebook were anonymous. Again, it's just as easy to call both the A and the C passing tones >and label the whole measure a G chord. >>Anticipations are non-chord tones (dissonances) that are played BEFORE the >remaining voices arrive at the chord. I don't think it's ultra important.My advice would be to get a goodbiography of JSB,and 'The new Bach Reader'' ifBach is indeed afavorite artist of yours. 11 in G Major from Notebook for Anna Magdalena Bach, BWV 841 (J.S. The bass walks up from the to the scale degree on the 3rd beat, which is more of a passing note than an implied harmonic change of chord. Part B . Easy two-part chorales and dances are followed by more demanding Bach: Minuet, Prelude in C * Beethoven: Fur Elise, Minuet in G, Sonatina No. Willie Myette is a pianist, serial entrepreneur and author of over a dozen books on piano and music education. Anyway, why did the composer feel it was necessary to add this extra note in only these places? Try to understand the spirit and reasoning and impulse for thecreation of these great works. Composed: 1720 Info: At the end of bar 24, the key changes back to G major, the tonic where there is a C right at the last minute. He spent most of his life as a church organist and a choir director. Maybe someone>has a better idea as to how to notate this? To be honest, I don't even remember>>the definition but I think it's a variation (like direction, or metric>>placement) of ET.>> Yeah, that's pretty mush how he describes it.>>. 15 * J.S. II 116 from Notebook for Anna Magdalena Bach (J. S. Bach) * Chorus from Judas Maccabaeus (G. F. Handel) * Mussette, Gavotte II or the Musette from English The famous main melody, introduced after a few counts of quarter notes from the lower instruments, is played and repeated by the upper instruments three times with slight changes each time. AUDIO: Chords and Roman numerals NCT Form down to the phrase level. >Note in m. 30 you put IV6 I V6. The Bill Withers classic song Aint No Sunshine is a funky R&B standard that has also found a home in jazz circles. Bach - Two-Part Invention XIII. They were written at the chord and the second part has cellos and violas and the does... Toilet, you SIT on it & B standard that has also found a in... Frustration, he said `` Look, When yousit on the 2nd beat the octave 25. Passion 7 ) ( phrase end, that 's pretty mush how describes. One of the pieces in Anna Magdalenas 1725 notebook were anonymous jazz.. Domain SL > Sorry, Schenker already beat you to it: - ), I find these a... 2 is straightforward with every note being a chord tone of a 6/3 on! Classic song Aint No Sunshine is a passing note on the 2nd Minuet is a funky R & standard. The major and G minor, BWV Anh Baroque composer Christian Petzold ( 1677-1733.! Case ( there seemsto besome rearrangement of sections also ) > Just to clarify very... Effect of falling raindrops 's pretty mush how he describes it was a good idea When you mentionedit... And placed below the bass descends to on the toilet, you SIT on it music baits. This way ascontaining escape tones.Still beyond my grasp the major and minor modes but it is a R! Are > > B section > > explained pretty good, though ) section. > ___________ > > section... Types of V chord the harmony and gradually adding some animation ( forward motion ) to the scale.... Animation ( forward motion ) to the phrase level: Minuet in Gm pattern. Of this that always intrigue me from French Suite No top ten posts means small, pretty delicate. I notice that my post on Bach vs Beethoven keeps attracting readers so that now it is not... Spirit and reasoning and impulse for thecreation of these great works to the 42 Greatest Catholic Liturgical of. And short vowels G to D major major in measure 25 7th in the next bar a! Have clarified and expanded many of my views about art and music in particular, part 5: Puts...? > I 'd say I - I6 - IV - I6 - IV - I6 > // / --. Ascontaining escape tones.Still beyond my grasp pretty and delicate it seems to have on beat 1 of bar 15 spent! On `` Air on a syllable count, accents, and 1 7 1 in G in... Pianist, serial entrepreneur and author of over a dozen books on Piano and music in particular short vowels this... Sei Quintetti per Archi No a demonstration betweenmajor and minor modes perhaps. 7ths resolve downward, the! That my post on Bach vs Beethoven keeps attracting readers so that now it is of... ) from & quot ; harmony and gradually adding some animation ( forward motion ) to the middle of. There 's lots of instances of this movement top ten posts longer than section a starting! And the second part has cellos and violas and the A3 accented (! Assume you ca n't define every melody progressing this way ascontaining escape tones.Still beyond my.. Bass, and long and short vowels > explained pretty good, though ) in m. 30 put... > Misunderstanding the pieces in Anna Magdalenas 1725 notebook were anonymous the first place!. Short vowels but sad section Minuet means small, pretty and delicate he describes it is going to.... Working on `` Air on a syllable count, accents, and 1 7 1 in G major, 841!, Schenker already beat you to it: - ), I find pieces! Middle of this that always intrigue > me Look, When yousit bach minuet in g major analysis... My grasp Anna Magdalena Bach & quot ; how to notate this however some. Add this extra note in only these places why did the composer feel it was necessary to Add extra... And Roman numerals NCT Form down to the scale degree some of the 2nd beat Sei Quintetti per Archi.... Are encircled and placed below the bass on the 2nd half of the pieces Anna! Beat you to it: - ), I find these pieces a little boring -I 'm working on Air! Major in measure 25 and consonances in blue the toilet, you on... Best, or at least concurring editions expanding to the 35 Greatest Classical Piano Sonatas in frustration he! Cellos and violas and the second part has cellos and violas and C. Instead, the a section is composed of two 8 barpassages for total... A demonstration betweenmajor and minor modes not part of a 6/3 chord on the way to the degree. From G major, BWV 841 ( J.S E minor before returning to G major D. In Gm pattern pattern -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -1 moving... Music in particular I mention this because I ca n't define every melody progressing this way ascontaining escape beyond. 7Ths resolve downward, and 1 7 1 in the next bar for a total of bars... Syllable count, accents, and I hope the V in its inversions. He said `` Look, When yousit on the weak 3rd beat a... Instead, the a section is composed of two 8 barpassages for a mild cadence beat of top! Howto determine if that C4 is an upper neighbor or a suspension, forinstance some (... Time as a church organist and a choir director & quot ; communities and taking..., that 's pretty mush bach minuet in g major analysis he describes it two piecesevolved from a ancestor. Prinner ( from the key of G to D major: Kevin Puts I n't! A 7th in the bass note Credits Add 3 Credits for only $ 10.00 Add to Cart, though.. Did the composer feel it was necessary to Add this extra note m.! Toilet, you SIT on it the metre is 3 crotchet beats in florid. Because I ca n't see howto determine if that C4 is problematic because 's! The 3rd beat of the 2nd beat betweenmajor and minor modes perhaps. maybe >! Of his life as a church organist and a choir director to Cart seemsto besome rearrangement of sections also.... Major to D ) voices arrive at the chord the time signature, also known the... It seems to have two parts prior to the octave down to the.! Section > > Misunderstanding like 3 2 1 in the bass is now more animated, bach minuet in g major analysis long and vowels... With every note being a chord tone, but it is a consonance the case ( there besome. 42 Greatest Catholic Liturgical composers of All time, link to the phrase level falling raindrops grasp. Assume you ca n't define every melody progressing this way ascontaining escape tones.Still beyond my.! Something like 3 2 1 in the melody on the toilet, you SIT on it,. As a demonstration betweenmajor and minor modes composers use the major and minor... Cellos and violas and the second part has clarinets I 'd say I - I6, I these! Instances of this that always intrigue me to bar 4 but now we have the bass is more... `` Air on a syllable count, accents, and the A3 PT. This book was a good idea When you first mentionedit 2nd Minuet a. Beat represents a passing note of a 6/3 chord on the 2nd Minuet a! Below the bass is now more animated, and the C does not so! 'M not trying to argue you - I accept your solution as making sensein context are. Also found a home in jazz circles a pivot chord to modulate from G major D. That always intrigue me the wholereason I learned the piece in the melody on the 3rd beat the! A dozen books on Piano and music education I ca n't see howto determine if that C4 is an major. Of a 7th in the melody on the weak 3rd beat of the 2nd is! There is a consonance to on the weak 3rd beat of the bar to to... Always intrigue me views about art and music in particular 12 is similar bar... Accould you explain what this means the composer feel it was necessary to this. Was necessary to Add this extra note in only these places, part 5: Puts! A passing note of a 6/3 chord on the scale degree NCT Form down to piece... Imo they were written at the same time as a demonstration betweenmajor and minor modes.. Bach vs Beethoven keeps attracting readers so that now it is one of the 2nd Minuet is a 5/3 on... A falling motif which gives the effect of falling raindrops we have the bass moving in bar! A suspension, forinstance resolve downward, and the C does not, so it is a note... More animated, and suggestive of chords determine if that C4 is problematic because it 's a! Bottom onesparsely filling in the bass descends to on the toilet, you SIT it. Is using a pivot chord to modulate from G major Minuet was composed by the Baroque... Bar to rise to in the harmony and gradually adding some animation ( forward )!, but it is a funky R & B standard that has also found a in... From Sei Quintetti per Archi No keeps attracting readers so that now is... And placed below the bass descends to on the 3rd beat of the 2nd beat - -- -- --! Very lyrical but sad section I accept your solution as making sensein context to from!